If you're a handmade artisan selling on Amazon Handmade, you've likely experienced the platform's limitations firsthand—restrictive policies, high fees, limited branding opportunities, and zero ownership of customer relationships. The good news? An Amazon Handmade to Shopify migration can transform your business by giving you complete control over your brand, customer experience, and profitability.
Making the switch from Amazon Handmade to Shopify isn't just about changing platforms—it's about taking ownership of your business's future. While Amazon provides built-in traffic, Shopify offers something far more valuable: the ability to build a sustainable, independent brand that you truly own. In this comprehensive guide, we'll walk you through everything you need to know about migrating from Amazon Handmade to Shopify, from the initial planning stages to post-migration growth strategies.
Whether you're frustrated with Amazon's fees, ready to build your own brand identity, or simply want more control over your customer relationships, this guide will provide you with a clear roadmap for a successful Amazon Handmade to Shopify migration.
Before diving into the how-to, let's explore why thousands of handmade sellers are making the switch to Shopify. Understanding these benefits will help you make an informed decision and stay motivated throughout the migration process.
On Amazon Handmade, you never truly own your customer data. Amazon controls all customer communications and prohibits you from building direct relationships with buyers. When you migrate to Shopify, you gain complete access to customer information, email addresses, and purchase history. This allows you to build an email list, create personalized marketing campaigns, and develop long-term customer relationships that drive repeat purchases.
Amazon Handmade charges a 15% referral fee on each sale, plus additional fees for fulfillment if you use FBA. These fees can significantly eat into your profit margins, especially for lower-priced items. Shopify operates on a transparent monthly subscription model (starting at $39/month for the Basic plan) with significantly lower transaction fees (2.9% + 30¢ for online credit card rates, or even lower with Shopify Payments). For most sellers, this translates to substantial cost savings and better profit margins.
Amazon Handmade offers minimal customization options. Your product listings look similar to every other seller's, making it difficult to stand out and build brand recognition. Shopify provides complete creative control over your store's design, allowing you to create a unique brand experience that reflects your artistic vision. You can customize everything from colors and fonts to layout and functionality, creating a memorable shopping experience that keeps customers coming back.
On Amazon, you're competing in a crowded marketplace where customers often shop by price rather than brand loyalty. Shopify gives you the tools to implement comprehensive marketing strategies including email marketing, social media integration, content marketing, and referral programs. You can build a community around your brand and create multiple touchpoints with customers beyond just product listings.
A successful migration requires careful planning. Rushing the process can result in lost sales, confused customers, and technical headaches. Here's how to create a solid migration plan.
Start by conducting a thorough audit of your Amazon Handmade presence. Document your total number of products, average monthly sales, top-performing items, seasonal trends, and customer demographics. Export all available data from Amazon Seller Central, including sales reports, customer reviews, and inventory levels. This information will guide your Shopify setup and help you prioritize which products to migrate first.
Don't try to complete your Amazon Handmade to Shopify migration overnight. A typical migration takes 4-8 weeks, depending on the size of your catalog and complexity of your business. Create a detailed timeline that includes research (1 week), Shopify setup (2 weeks), product migration (2-3 weeks), testing (1 week), and soft launch (1 week). Build in buffer time for unexpected challenges.
You have three main options for transitioning from Amazon Handmade to Shopify. The gradual approach involves running both platforms simultaneously while slowly shifting focus to Shopify—this minimizes risk but requires managing two storefronts. The hybrid approach maintains a reduced presence on Amazon while building your Shopify store—ideal for testing the waters. The complete migration involves closing your Amazon Handmade shop and moving entirely to Shopify—this works best when you have a strong existing customer base or email list to migrate.
Now let's dive into the practical steps of migrating your handmade business from Amazon to Shopify. Follow these steps carefully to ensure a smooth transition.
Begin by signing up for a Shopify account and selecting your plan. The Basic Shopify plan ($39/month) is sufficient for most handmade sellers starting out. Choose a memorable domain name that reflects your brand—ideally something short, easy to spell, and relevant to your products. Shopify offers free domain registration for the first year with annual plans.
Select a theme that showcases your handmade products effectively. Shopify's theme store offers both free and premium options designed specifically for artisan and handmade businesses. Look for themes with large product images, clean layouts, and mobile responsiveness. Popular choices for handmade sellers include Craft, Narrative, and Brooklyn.
Log into Amazon Seller Central and navigate to the Inventory section. Use the "Export All Listings" feature to download your product catalog as a CSV file. This file will include product titles, descriptions, prices, SKUs, and other essential data. Also export your sales history, customer reviews (for reference), and any other relevant reports. While you can't directly import customer data from Amazon, you can use this information to understand your audience better.
This is the most time-intensive part of your Amazon Handmade to Shopify migration. While you can use CSV import tools to speed up the process, you'll need to optimize each listing for Shopify's platform. Start with your best-selling products to get your store generating revenue quickly.
For each product, write compelling, SEO-optimized titles and descriptions. Unlike Amazon, you have complete freedom to tell your brand story and connect emotionally with customers. Include details about your creative process, materials used, and what makes each piece unique. Take high-quality product photos from multiple angles—Shopify allows unlimited images per product, so showcase every detail.
Set up product variants (size, color, material) using Shopify's variant system. Organize products into collections to make navigation easier for customers. Create collections based on product type, price range, occasion, or any other logical grouping that makes sense for your business.
Set up your payment processing through Shopify Payments or a third-party gateway like PayPal or Stripe. Configure your shipping settings, including zones, rates, and any free shipping thresholds. For handmade products, consider offering multiple shipping options (standard, expedited, and overnight) to accommodate different customer needs.
Create essential store policies including return and exchange policies, privacy policy, terms of service, and shipping policy. These build trust with customers and protect your business legally. Shopify provides policy generators to help you create these documents.
One challenge of leaving Amazon is losing that built-in traffic. Compensate by implementing strong SEO from day one. Optimize your homepage, collection pages, and product pages with relevant keywords. Write descriptive meta titles and meta descriptions for every page. Use alt text for all product images to improve accessibility and SEO.
Create a blog on your Shopify store to drive organic traffic. Write content about your creative process, care instructions for your products, gift guides, and other topics your target audience cares about. This content marketing strategy will help you build authority and attract customers through search engines.
Install Google Analytics and connect it to your Shopify store to track visitor behavior and sales performance. Set up Facebook Pixel and other tracking pixels if you plan to run paid advertising. Install essential apps from the Shopify App Store, including email marketing tools (like Klaviyo or Omnisend), review apps (like Loox or Judge.me), and a referral program app (like ReferralCandy).
Create your email marketing foundation by setting up welcome email sequences, abandoned cart recovery emails, and post-purchase follow-up campaigns. These automated emails will help you convert visitors and build customer loyalty from day one.
Your existing Amazon customers are valuable assets, but Amazon's policies make it challenging to bring them to your new Shopify store. Here's how to navigate this transition strategically and ethically.
While you can't directly email Amazon customers about your new store, you can include package inserts with your Amazon orders. Create attractive thank-you cards or product care instruction cards that include your new Shopify store URL and an incentive to visit (like a discount code for first-time purchases). Make sure these inserts comply with Amazon's policies by focusing on providing value rather than overtly advertising.
If you've built a social media following while selling on Amazon Handmade, announce your new Shopify store to your followers. Create excitement by offering exclusive launch discounts or early access to new products. Use Instagram Shopping, Facebook Shops, and Pinterest Product Pins to drive traffic directly to your Shopify store.
When reaching out to existing customers through allowed channels, clearly communicate why they should shop directly from your Shopify store. Emphasize benefits like exclusive products not available on Amazon, better customer service, loyalty rewards, early access to new collections, and potentially better pricing since you're not paying Amazon's fees.
Inventory management is critical during your Amazon Handmade to Shopify migration. Poor inventory tracking can lead to overselling, disappointed customers, and damaged reputation.
If you're running both Amazon and Shopify simultaneously, consider using inventory management software that syncs across platforms. Apps like Sellbrite, Inventory Source, or Listing Mirror can help prevent overselling by updating inventory counts in real-time across all your sales channels.
As a handmade seller, your production capacity is limited. Calculate how many items you can realistically produce per week and set inventory levels accordingly. Consider using Shopify's inventory tracking to automatically hide products when they're out of stock, or allow backorders with clear communication about production time.
Many handmade sellers work on a made-to-order basis. Shopify makes this easy to communicate through product descriptions and estimated shipping times. Be transparent about production timelines and build in buffer time to account for unexpected delays. Set up automated order confirmation emails that clearly state when customers can expect their handmade items to ship.
Completing your Amazon Handmade to Shopify migration is just the beginning. Now it's time to leverage Shopify's powerful features to grow your handmade business beyond what was possible on Amazon.
One of the biggest advantages of owning your customer relationships is the ability to turn customers into brand advocates. Implement a referral program using apps like ReferralCandy to incentivize existing customers to refer friends and family. Offer rewards like discounts, free shipping, or exclusive products to both the referrer and the referred customer. Referral programs are particularly effective for handmade businesses because customers who love your unique products naturally want to share them with others.
Create valuable content that attracts your ideal customers and establishes you as an expert in your craft. Write blog posts about your creative process, the history of your craft, styling tips for your products, or gift guides featuring your items. Share behind-the-scenes videos on social media showing how you create your products. This content builds emotional connections with customers and improves your SEO, driving organic traffic to your store.
Email marketing delivers an average ROI of $42 for every $1 spent, making it one of the most effective channels for ecommerce growth. Build your email list through website pop-ups, exit-intent offers, and lead magnets like downloadable care guides or exclusive discount codes. Segment your email list based on purchase history, browsing behavior, and customer preferences to send targeted campaigns that convert.
Continuously test and improve your Shopify store's conversion rate. Use A/B testing to experiment with different product page layouts, call-to-action buttons, and checkout processes. Add trust signals like customer reviews, security badges, and money-back guarantees. Implement live chat or chatbot support to answer customer questions in real-time. Even small improvements in conversion rate can significantly impact your revenue.
Shopify makes it easy to sell across multiple channels from one central dashboard. Add sales channels like Facebook Shops, Instagram Shopping, Pinterest, and even in-person sales through Shopify POS. Consider selling on other marketplaces like Etsy (which pairs well with Shopify) while maintaining your independent store. This multichannel approach reduces dependence on any single platform while maximizing your reach.
Every Amazon Handmade to Shopify migration comes with challenges. Here's how to address the most common obstacles you'll face.
The biggest challenge is replacing Amazon's built-in traffic. Expect lower sales initially while you build your audience. Overcome this by investing in paid advertising (Google Ads, Facebook Ads, Instagram Ads) to drive targeted traffic. Focus on building your email list aggressively. Partner with influencers in your niche for product features and reviews. Be patient—building sustainable traffic takes time, but the long-term benefits of owning your audience far outweigh the short-term pain.
Shopify is user-friendly, but there's still a learning curve, especially if you're not tech-savvy. Take advantage of Shopify's extensive documentation, video tutorials, and 24/7 customer support. Join Shopify Facebook groups and forums where experienced sellers share tips and answer questions. Consider hiring a Shopify expert for initial setup if you're completely overwhelmed—the investment often pays for itself in time saved and mistakes avoided.
Amazon Prime has conditioned customers to expect fast, free shipping. As an independent seller, you may not be able to match these expectations. Be transparent about shipping times and costs upfront. Offer multiple shipping options so customers can choose based on their priorities. Provide exceptional customer service and packaging to create a premium experience that justifies longer shipping times.
Before completing your Amazon Handmade to Shopify migration, address these important legal and financial matters.
Operating your own Shopify store may have different tax implications than selling through Amazon. Consult with an accountant to ensure you're properly collecting and remitting sales tax in all required jurisdictions. Shopify offers built-in tax calculation tools, but you're responsible for compliance. Consider whether your current business structure (sole proprietorship, LLC, etc.) still makes sense as you scale.
As mentioned earlier, create comprehensive store policies that protect both you and your customers. Include clear information about returns, exchanges, custom orders, production times, and what happens if items are damaged in shipping. These policies set expectations and reduce disputes.
Consider business insurance to protect against product liability claims, shipping issues, and other potential problems. As an independent business owner, you have more direct liability than when selling through Amazon's platform. Research options like general liability insurance and product liability insurance specific to handmade businesses.
A complete Amazon Handmade to Shopify migration typically takes 4-8 weeks, depending on the size of your product catalog and the complexity of your business. This timeline includes planning, setting up your Shopify store, migrating products, testing, and soft launching. However, you can start generating sales on Shopify within 2-3 weeks if you prioritize migrating your best-selling products first. Remember that building sustainable traffic to match your Amazon sales may take 3-6 months of consistent marketing effort.
Yes, many sellers successfully operate both platforms simultaneously, at least during the transition period. This hybrid approach minimizes risk by maintaining your Amazon revenue stream while building your Shopify presence. Use inventory management software to sync stock levels across both platforms and prevent overselling. However, be aware that managing two storefronts requires more time and effort. Many sellers eventually phase out Amazon once their Shopify store generates consistent revenue, but some maintain both channels as part of a diversified sales strategy.
Unfortunately, you cannot directly transfer Amazon customer reviews to Shopify due to Amazon's terms of service and data ownership policies. However, you can use your Amazon reviews as social proof in other ways. Screenshot positive reviews to include in your marketing materials (with customer permission). Reference review themes in your product descriptions (e.g., "Customers love the durability of this handmade bag"). Most importantly, focus on collecting new reviews on your Shopify store using review apps like Judge.me, Loox, or Yotpo. Offer incentives like discount codes for customers who leave reviews to build up your review base quickly.
The basic costs include your Shopify subscription ($39/month for Basic Shopify, $105/month for Shopify, or $399/month for Advanced Shopify), domain name ($14/year, free first year with annual plans), and any premium theme ($180-$350 one-time purchase, though free themes work well too). Budget for essential apps like email marketing ($20-100/month depending on list size), review apps ($15-30/month), and potentially inventory management software if running multiple channels ($50-200/month). Initial marketing costs for paid advertising should be budgeted at $500-2,000 to drive initial traffic. Total first-year costs typically range from $1,500-5,000 depending on your needs and growth strategy.
Your sales history and data remain in Amazon Seller Central even after you close your Amazon Handmade shop. Download and save all reports, sales data, and analytics before closing your account, as access may be limited after closure. While you can't transfer this data directly into Shopify, it's valuable for understanding your customer demographics, seasonal trends, and best-selling products. Use these insights to inform your Shopify strategy, pricing, and inventory planning. Keep in mind that Amazon owns customer contact information, so you cannot export customer emails or contact details for marketing purposes.
Replacing Amazon's traffic requires a multi-channel marketing approach. Start with SEO optimization of your product pages and blog content to attract organic search traffic. Leverage social media platforms like Instagram, Pinterest, and Facebook where visual products perform well. Implement email marketing with welcome sequences and abandoned cart recovery. Run targeted paid advertising on Google, Facebook, and Instagram. Collaborate with influencers and bloggers in your niche. Participate in online communities and forums related to your craft. Implement a referral program to turn customers into brand advocates. Most successful Shopify stores use a combination of these strategies rather than relying on a single traffic source.
Shopify is generally better for handmade sellers who want to build a long-term, sustainable brand with complete control over customer relationships, branding, and profit margins. You own your customer data, pay lower fees (typically saving 10-12% per sale), and have unlimited customization options. However, Amazon Handmade provides built-in traffic and credibility that's valuable for brand-new sellers. The ideal approach for many sellers is starting on Amazon Handmade to validate your products and build initial sales, then migrating to Shopify once you've established market fit. Shopify offers superior long-term growth potential and business value, while Amazon provides easier short-term sales at the cost of higher fees and less control.
No advanced technical skills are required for an Amazon Handmade to Shopify migration. Shopify is designed to be user-friendly for non-technical users, with drag-and-drop store builders, pre-designed themes, and intuitive interfaces. Basic computer skills and the ability to follow tutorials are sufficient for most sellers. Shopify provides extensive documentation, video tutorials, and 24/7 customer support to help you through any challenges. That said, having some familiarity with basic concepts like CSV files, image editing, and website navigation will make the process smoother. If you're completely overwhelmed, you can hire a Shopify expert for initial setup (typically $500-2,000), but most handmade sellers successfully complete the migration themselves.
An Amazon Handmade to Shopify migration represents more than just a platform change—it's a strategic decision to take full ownership of your handmade business. While Amazon Handmade offers the convenience of built-in traffic, Shopify provides something far more valuable: complete control over your brand, customer relationships, and long-term business growth.
Yes, the migration process requires effort, planning, and patience. You'll face challenges like building traffic from scratch, learning new systems, and investing in marketing. But the rewards—lower fees, higher profit margins, owned customer data, unlimited branding potential, and true business independence—make it worthwhile for sellers committed to building sustainable, scalable handmade businesses.
By following the strategies outlined in this guide, you can successfully navigate your Amazon Handmade to Shopify migration while minimizing disruption to your sales. Start with careful planning, migrate your products strategically, implement strong marketing from day one, and focus on building genuine customer relationships. Remember that building a successful independent ecommerce business is a marathon, not a sprint. Give yourself grace during the transition period and stay focused on your long-term vision.
Ready to take the next step? Start by signing up for a Shopify free trial and begin planning your migration today. Your handmade business deserves a platform that supports your growth and values your unique creative vision—and that platform is Shopify.
Want to supercharge your Shopify store's growth after migration? Implement a referral program with ReferralCandy to turn your customers into your best marketers. Learn more about how referral marketing can drive sustainable growth for your handmade business.
Raúl Galera is the Growth Lead at ReferralCandy, where they’ve helped 30,000+ eCommerce brands drive sales through referrals and word-of-mouth marketing. Over the past 8+ years, Raúl has worked hands-on with DTC merchants of all sizes (from scrappy Shopify startups to household names) helping them turn happy customers into revenue-driving advocates. Raúl’s been featured on dozens of top eCommerce podcasts, contributed to leading industry publications, and regularly speaks about customer acquisition, retention, and brand growth at industry events.
Grow your sales at a ridiculously
lower CAC.
